Being thrifty is a fantastic way to save money each month. Unfortunately, not every frugal practice is truly a good way to cut costs. In a recent online discussion, commenters shared frugal things they thought would help them reduce spending but didn’t prove to be the savings they thought it would be. Here are our top 11 choices.
1. Growing Your Food
Everyone knows the frugal person who swears that growing their own food has saved them thousands of dollars annually. However, most people realize this isn’t the case — the associated costs add up. “I always expect growing my food to be more frugal than it is,” admits one woman.
“It can be frugal, but if you’re buying soil and fertilizer, in your specific case, it probably isn’t. I enjoy doing it and don’t let the costs get out of hand, but I tend to spend more than I plan at the start of the season.”
2. Buying in Bulk
One of the biggest misconceptions about being frugal is that there’s always money to be saved if you buy items in bulk.
In theory, this is correct, but many people who go down this road quickly realize that this strategy only works for certain products — and it’s rarely wise to buy perishable items in bulk.
3. Counting on Amazon
There was a time when Amazon undercut all of its competitors, setting itself up as the online superstore it is today.
Now that Amazon has a firm grip over most e-commerce, their prices have slowly increased over the years. So stop counting on Amazon – you can find better deals elsewhere. If you shop on the site, look for ways to earn free Amazon gift cards to lower your total spending.
4. Buying Sustainable Clothes
The premise of sustainable clothes is that they’re better for the environment and last a long time. But unfortunately, countless people claim that the markup they pay isn’t worth it.
“Those clothes are supposed to last longer, but my normal clothes also last quite long,” reports one woman. “Maybe it makes a difference in 15 years or so, but until then, I’ll just treat my clothes carefully.”
5. Cheap Bedding and Towels
Thanks to enticing product descriptions, many people find the deal of the century when they order cheap bedding and towels from online retailers.
Unfortunately, these seemingly innocuous positive product reviews hide the truth: These products are subpar. You’ll have to pay up if you want good sheets and bedding.
6. Shopping at Thrift Stores
Thanks to more deal-obsessed people succumbing to the trend of shopping at thrift stores, many people confess there aren’t as many good finds in 2023.
Like most businesses, inflation has hit thrift stores and second-hand shops — and as a result, it’s no longer a reliable place to find bargains.
7. Homemade Laundry Detergent
Not only is making your laundry detergent very labor-intensive, but many people can’t believe its effect on their clothes. Some people find out the hard way that nothing beats buying name-brand laundry detergent for convenience and effectiveness.
8. Using Milk Instead of Creamer
Frugal coffee addicts, listen up: If you’re trying to save money by using milk instead of creamer, it’s not worth it! “I thought I was saving money, but the amount of milk it takes to lighten my coffee the way I like it meant I was burning through milk like crazy,” admits one woman. “I went through nearly an entire gallon a week on coffee alone.”
9. Keeping Old Appliances
When it comes to being energy efficient, nothing beats modern-day appliances like refrigerators and washing machines. Yet, countless people have stubbornly kept their decades-old appliances, never realizing the sky-high energy costs of this decision.
10. Cutting the Cord on Cable
Cutting the cord on cable is a fantastic way to save money, until it’s not. If you leave your monthly subscription for five or six paid streaming services you’re going to sacrifice a lot of the savings you clawed back by ditching cable in the first place.
Instead, choose one service and watch the content you like, cancel it and move on to a different service. Combine that with using free streaming apps and an over-the-air antenna and you’ll net big savings.
11. Backyard Chickens
Do you like the idea of going out to your backyard and getting a few eggs? It may not be as thrifty as you might think.
“After making a coop, buying chicks, buying bedding, waterers, chicken food, starter food, fencing, heated water bowl, scratch grains, etc. I could have bought a lifetime supply of the best organic, free range, cruelty free chicken eggs from the local co-op. Not to mention poultry are very destructive to landscaping. I do enjoy them, but I continue to invest time and money,” says one person.
Unless you like the activity of raising chickens, it’s often more affordable to buy them elsewhere.
35 Proven Ways to Save Money Every Month
Many people believe it’s impossible to save money. Or, they think saving $20 or $50 a month won’t amount to much. Both are incorrect. There are many simple money-saving tips that can amount to big savings. You just have to start one, then another, to increase your savings.
How to Become Rich Quickly
Everyone wants to become rich quickly. While not always possible, there are legitimate ways to become wealthy. Follow these methods and you’ll be on the road to riches.
15 Best Alternatives to Cable
You don’t necessarily need live TV to replace cable. Many streaming services offer quality content and good features to slash your bill.
Best Places to Buy Discount Shoes Online
Shoes can get expensive, especially with a growing family. Instead of buying cheap footwear, shop at the best retailer to get discount prices. Outfit your family without going cheap.
13 Legit Ways to Earn Free PayPal Money
Free cash sounds too good to be true, but there are legit ways to earn free PayPal money that you can use right now to earn a little extra spending money.
This thread inspired this post.